Friday, 4 May 2007

Separating Louisiana and Northern Waterthrushes

Well, we had planned to start with gulls, had made several announcements and then kept the world waiting (in case the world had noticed) but now finally we have a lift-off: the first post in what will surely become a series of blog cooperation projects between Charlie Moores and yours truly, Belltower Birder. Within this cooperation we plan to combine whatever our respective strengths are to see if we can't come up with a good piece of bird blogging that each of us would not have been able to achieve himself. This time, it is the identification of the two waterthrushes and we hope it will prove helpful during this - and the next few - migration periods.
You can find the very same post on Charlie's blog here, by the way, as that's how the cooperation works.

It's spring, migrants are everywhere, and you catch a glimpse of what looks like a small warbler walking in a damp, shaded area. As you move closer you get better views- it's a brownish bird, streaked below, possibly a waterthrush, but - crucially - it's not calling. Your prize may fly off at any moment, so just what features do you need to concentrate on to make a positive ID...?

The two species of Waterthrush,
Louisiana Waterthrush Seiurus motacilla and Northern Waterthrush Seiurus noveboracensis, are very similar to each other but are themselves easily distinguished from other species within the North American wood warblers. They basically form their own genus Seiurus, with the only other member being the strikingly different Ovenbird Seiurus aurocapilla. The Ovenbird though is so different from the two waterthrush species (in multiple aspects) that many authorities consider a review necessary that would then place the waterthrushes in a genus of their own. All three species, Ovenbird, Louisiana and Northern Waterthrush, share the following field characters that can be used to separate them from other North American wood warblers:
  • They are brown above and pale (buffy or white) below with bold brown streaks.
  • They are largely ground-dwelling and only seldom seen on branches.
The Ovenbird is easily distinguished from the waterthrushes by its lack of a pale supercilium (the “eyebrow”), its whitish ring around the eye, warm reddish-brown crown and - frankly - by its completely different appearance.

Ovenbird Seiurus aurocapilla

So basically, unless a vagrant Redwing Turdus iliacus from Eurasia is taken into account, a ground-dwelling small song bird that is brown above, pale below with brown stripes and shows a pale supercilium is bound to be a waterthrush.

So far so good, but unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how much you enjoy a good challenge) this is where easy ends and not-so-easy begins: the identification and separation of the two species of waterthrush... When confronted with a waterthrush, these are the field characters which we have found can be used to distinguish one from the other (field-guides do mention other characters ie Louisiana's buffy supralorals and buffy rear-flanks but in our experience these are difficult to see under normal viewing conditions):

The movement of the tail and rear body
Both species constantly bob their tail and rear body, but there is a slight yet distinct difference between the two.
Northern Waterthrush
: a plain up-and-down bobbing of the tail and rear body.
Louisiana Waterthrush
: a more "sinewy" bobbing that includes also moving the tail/rear body to the sides.

The shape and colour of the eyebrow
Northern Waterthrush: narrowing at the rear and very often yellowish or buffy white.
Louisiana Waterthrush: broad, bold and white, and not narrowing.

The shape and length of the bill
Northern Waterthrush: rather short and thin, the lower mandible being thin and straight as well.
Louisiana Waterthrush
: long and strong, the lower mandible often appears strong and bent upwards, (very remotely similar to a Yellow-billed Loon Gavia adamsii!).

This Northern Waterthrush shows the typical, rather thin supercilium and a long and thin bill.

The supercilium is more bold and bright on Louisiana and the bill appears a bit longer and especially stronger than on Northern

Patterning of the chin/throat
Northern Waterthrush: most birds have a finely striped chin, but some can show a white chin comparable to Louisiana.
Louisiana Waterthrush
: always without fine stripes, pure white.

A striped chin therefore is diagnostic for Northern Waterthrush, but an unstriped chin cannot be used to definitely identify a bird as Louisiana Waterthrush!

The chin of most Northern Waterthrushes shows very fine streaks

Louisiana Waterthrushes always show a plain white chin without streaks

Colour of the breast and belly
Northern Waterthrush: varies between whitish and yellowish, but never shows a contrast between the tone of the breast and the flanks.
Louisiana Waterthrush
: always whitish with buffy rear flanks.

Pattern of stripes below
Northern Waterthrush: often relatively dense, usually more heavily striped than Louisiana.
Louisiana Waterthrush
: often relatively few.

An additional difference that we came to notice but still needs to be tested in the field is the patterning of the stripes on the rear flanks: Louisiana Waterthrushes tend to show two parallel and straight lines along the rear flanks, very nicely patterned as the small individual stripes are completely in line. In Northern Waterthrushes, these lines on the rear flanks still show the individual stripes but they are not parallel but in a pattern reminiscent of a spruce twig, pointing in different directions. There is a considerable amount of individual variation however and this field character will not work on all birds.

A Northern Waterthrush showing the "spruce twig pattern on the rear flanks

A Louisiana Waterthrush showing two nice parallel lines on the rear flanks

Leg colouration
Northern Waterthrush: dull, darker pink.
Louisiana Waterthrush
: bright pink, almost reddish.

The typically dark, dull pink legs of a Northern Waterthrush are often difficult to see against the usually dark and muddy background of its preferred habitat

The legs of a Louisiana Waterthrush are usually very bright pink and in strong contrast to the same dark background

In general, the Northern Waterthrush appears more as a "dull and dirty" bird, with its darker legs, tainted supercilium and often yellowish tinge below. The Louisiana Waterthrush in contrast always gives the impression of a neat, clean and stylish bird, based on its clean white supercilium, bright legs and white colouration of the breast and belly. This difference might not work in all birds, but describes the general appearance quite well as can be seen on the two images below.

A typical "dull and dirty" Northern Waterthrush

A typical "nice, neat and clean" Louisiana Waterthrush

All these field characters are well established and should allow the identification of (almost) all the waterthrushes one encounters. However, most of these field marks are of a relative character and therefore require a certain amount of experience with at least one of the species, most likely to be the more common Northern Waterthrush. How else is one to determine if the bill of a bird is long or longer, if the stripes on the breast and belly of a bird are numerous or less numerous and if a whitish supercilium is bright or obviously bright? Furthermore, some of the field marks mentioned above are subject to individual or geographical variation and not entirely foolproof as rarely single individuals of one species will show a character more typical of the other species.

We would therefore like to introduce here one more field character that might be useful in identifying all individuals, regardless of geographic origin or individual variation as the field mark we present here was shown in other species to be rather stable and reliable. However, this field character cannot be regarded as established because we have only been able to test it on a limited amount of individuals in the field and on photographs of both species we were able to study.

From these limited examinations it appears that the Louisiana Waterthrush shows a primary projection that is significantly longer than that of the Northern Waterthrush. Primary projection is the extent to which the primaries project beyond the tertials on the folded wing of a bird.

The primary projection can be measured by comparing the primary projection with the length of the visible tertials and estimating the relative difference in %, as shown in the following image. (This may sound complicated but it’s actually a rather easy process once you become familiar with which feathers are tertials and which are primaries.)

The primary projection [A] of the Northern Waterthrush depicted above is roughly 50-75% the length of the visible tertials [B] whereas it is closer to 100% in the Louisiana Waterthrush seen below.


The identification of both species of waterthrush appears quite difficult at first but is a rather straight-forward affair in most birds once the following key features are checked:

  • the movement of the tail and rear body (up-and-down only, or up-and-down and also sideways)
  • the patterning of the chin (white or with stripes)
  • the supercilium (small and often yellowish or bold and white)
  • the colouration of breast and belly (yellowish/buffy or pure white)
  • the leg colouration (dull or bright pink)
  • the structure of the bill (slender or strong)

Due to individual and geographic variation, not all birds show the field characters normally typical for the species and the identification should thus always rest on as many of the field marks mentioned above as possible.

Based on our limited experience with both species, we present one further field character that might be less prone to vary and might facilitate the identification of even the more tricky individuals:

  • the primary projection (length of the primaries projecting beyond the tertials on the folded wing) of the Louisiana Waterthrush is close to 100% of the visible length of the tertials whereas this value is closer to 50-75% in Northern Waterthrushes.

We hope this apparently new but still largely unconfirmed field character inspires birdwatchers in North America to specifically take a deeper interest in the identification of the two species and test our suggestion in the field. We welcome any feed back and opinion on the subject.

Jochen Roeder and Charlie Moores, May 2007

Text by Jochen Roeder (, photos by Charlie Moores (
Photographs taken in Central Park, New York, April 2007, except Ovenbird taken at Garrett Mountain, NY May 2006


Larry said...

I'm going to have to read this carefully-I recently posted a dark pic of a waterthrush and we weren't sure which one it was.

Anonymous said...

Great cooperative is it a German and an Englishman know more about IDing North American birds than 99% of North Americans?

And you guys forgot one very key way to tell them (I only mention this because every other aspect of figuring them out is so detailed and complete that it seems a shame to leave that bit out).

Patrick B. said...

Bravo to Jochen and Charlie! Very well done. Any idea on the wintering range of these 2 species? Would it make sense that the Louisiana migrates further due to longer primary projection?

inchirieri apartamente cluj said...

Really great stuff! And awesome pictures. I got all the details necessary to make a distinction between these two tips of birds: Northern Waterthrush and Louisiana Waterthrush.

news games said...

Yeii !! I have learn something today about birds...I am realy honored to se how much work have you put into these article.

Anonymous said...

In fact, the uѕer consumρtіοn of televіsion and рrint media, electгoniс media, Internet ρromotiοn business and other neweг formѕ.
Givе details of who are business the people running the company, wheгe shе
staгred аs Cassy the vivаcious, clаssic dumb blonde.
Τhe music I liѕten to, the drama I loѵe, the restаuгаnts
I еat in, thе pгoject-size and
nature of work has been changing quitе dгamaticаlly.

Fееl free to ѕurf to my blog ... internet marketing forums

Anonymous said...

Early experimental research exploring the impact of violent
video games for wii on children. Credit: University of UtahMedical Xpress Can video games
for wii help patients with several chronic diseases.
Other toy and video-game makers will watch Infinity's fortunes with interest. You learn to map the virtual world.

Also visit my homepage ... video game Walkthroughs

Anonymous said...

I just ran across this post as I gear up to study for spring migration and wanted to let you know it is still helping somebody out there! :-)

- Lindsey

Mario Cohn-Haft said...

hey gentlemen. nice piece! how's the primary projection character working out? i just tried it on a photo of what appears (by all marks) to be brazil's first lousisiana waterthrush and it supported my ID. has there been follow up on the use of this mark elsewhere since you posted it? thanks for any feedback.

Mario Cohn-Haft said...

hello folks. not sure this blog is being maintained anymore, but thought i'd add a couple follow-up comments related to my first entry in march of 2016. our paper on some new bird species for brazil came out not too long ago and cites this blog entry on ID of waterthrushes. in that paper, we try out and further corroborate the primary projection field mark and also mention habitat differences that may work on both breeding and wintering grounds.

here's the reference:

Laranjeiras et al. 2019. Three bird species new to Brazil from the Serra da Mocidade, a remote mountain in Roraima. Revista Brasileira de Ornitologia 27(4): 275–283.

anyone can get a pdf of the article directly from this link at the journal's website:

by the way, this blog contacted me automatically because of the new post above, which actually appears to be simply advertising and not related to this blog in any constructive way. did get me to check the blog though.

best, mario

Unknown said...

takipçi satın al
instagram takipçi satın al

Unknown said...


Unknown said...

ucuz takipçi
ucuz takipçi
tiktok izlenme satın al
binance güvenilir mi
okex güvenilir mi
paribu güvenilir mi
bitexen güvenilir mi
coinbase güvenilir mi
instagram takipçi satın al

شركة كواليتي للخدمات المنزلية said...

شركة تنظيف سجاد بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالدمام
شركة تسليك مجاري بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات الدمام

اوائل المثالى said...

كشف تسربات بالدمام said...

Thanks For this great content. Really Enjoyed.Keep It up. 슬롯머신 said...

I really like looking at and I believe this website got some really useful stuff on it. 카지노사이트프로 said...

Simply desire to say your article is as amazing. The clearness on your post is simply spectacular and that i could assume you are a professional on this subject.
스포츠토토 said...

Your blog is really nice. Its sound really good

evolution said...

What a post I've been looking for! I'm very happy to finally read this post. evolution Thank you very much. Can I refer to your post on my website? Your post touched me a lot and helped me a lot. If you have any questions, please visit my site and read what kind of posts I am posting. I am sure it will be interesting.

Tomy Goldenson said...

Nice & Informative Blog ! We offer welcome to yorkie puppies nearme. Check it out!...
puppies for sale near me
yorkie puppies with home training
where to buy Yorkie
Yorkie Female Puppies for sale
Yorkie puppies ready for their forever homes

Unknown said...

Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. 먹튀검증 and I am very happy to see your post just in time and it was a great help. Thank you ! Leave your blog address below. Please visit me anytime!

샌즈카지노 said...

How can you think of this? I thought about this, but I couldn't solve it as well as you.샌즈카지노I am so amazing and cool you are. I think you will help me. I hope you can help me.

스포츠토토사이트 said...

I was impressed by your writing. Your writing is impressive. I want to write like you.스포츠토토사이트 I hope you can read my post and let me know what to modify. My writing is in I would like you to visit my blog.

Unknown said...

Incredible post I should state and much obliged for the data. Instruction is unquestionably a sticky subject. Be that as it may, is still among the main themes of our opportunity. I value your post and anticipate more. 메이저저사이트

우리카지노 said...

Hello, I am one of the most impressed people in your article. 우리카지노 What you wrote was very helpful to me. Thank you. Actually, I run a site similar to you. If you have time, could you visit my site? Please leave your comments after reading what I wrote. If you do so, I will actively reflect your opinion. I think it will be a great help to run my site. Have a good day.

바카라사이트 said...

I've been searching for hours on this topic and finally found your post. 바카라사이트, I have read your post and I am very impressed. We prefer your opinion and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion. When would you like to visit my site?

메가슬롯 said...

When I read an article on this topic, 메가슬롯 the first thought was profound and difficult, and I wondered if others could understand.. My site has a discussion board for articles and photos similar to this topic. Could you please visit me when you have time to discuss this topic?

안전놀이터추천 said...

Hello, I read the post well. 안전놀이터추천 It's a really interesting topic and it has helped me a lot. In fact, I also run a website with similar content to your posting. Please visit once

메가슬롯 said...

As the Internet develops further in the future, I think we need to collect materials that people might be interested in. Among the data to be collected, your 메가슬롯 will also be included.

슬롯사이트 said...

I've been searching for hours on this topic and finally found your post. 슬롯사이트, I have read your post and I am very impressed. We prefer your opinion and will visit this site frequently to refer to your opinion. When would you like to visit my site?

파워볼사이트 said...

I've been looking for photos and articles on this topic over the past few days due to a school assignment, 파워볼사이트 and I'm really happy to find a post with the material I was looking for! I bookmark and will come often! Thanks :D

casinoapi said...

There are also articles on these topics on my blog and I hope you visit once and have a deep discussion!casino api

ركن الرحاب said...

شركة تعقيم بالقصيم
fi alfatrat al'akhirat wabaed al'iintishar alkabir lifayrus kuruna fi kafat 'anha' alealam , fa'asbahat eamaliaat albahth ean sharikat taeqim bialqasim kathiratan min 'ajl eamaliaat altaeqim lilmanazil walshuqaq walfilaat

شركة مكافحة الحمام بالقصيم

alkathir min alsukaan fi manazil buridat yueanun min kathrat alhamam alnaajim ean kathrat alhamaamat bial'iidafat 'iilaa alraayihat alkarihat

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالقصيم
sharikat mukafahat hasharat bialqasim tuqadim al'iibadat walnihayiyat lilsarasir sawa' kanat alzaahif minha 'aw altaayir , tilk alhasharat dhat almazhar almuqaziz waltaathir alsalbii ealaa alsihat lima tabuthuh min jarathim wamikrubat bialtaeamif'iidha lahazna 'akthar makan tatajamae fih

شركة تنظيف مكيفات بالقصيم
tuetabar eamaliat mutakamilat eamaliat altanzif alati taqum biha eamaliat altanzif alati taqum biha alsharikat , hayth yatajahaluha hayth yatarakam alghubar dakhil almarawih walmurashahat waldawaghit wabayanatihi

شركة تنظيف منازل بالقصيم

sharikat tanzif bialqasim almutakhasisat fi tanzif alshuqaq walfilal walmakatib walsharikat altijariat aleamilat fi majal aleamal altijarii fi majal altanzif bitadribina bialtariqat alhadithat fi majal alnazafa ... nadman jawdat alkhidmat wanaqum 'asafaha bi'asrae al'asear fi alnazafat wanaqum bitanzifiha

kevin said...

It is really a very informative and interesting article. I want to say more thankyou about this beautiful blog. Turkish online visa is a fast track online visa application system. It is the best time to apply for a Turkey visa online . All Museums, Attractions, Restaurants, Nightclubs, Bards are Open. And this time the temperature of Turkey is also very favorable to visit

Unkonwn said...

شركة ماستر تك هى شركة تطوير وتصميم وتصنيع العديد من ماكينات التعبئة والتغليف وخطوط الانتاج .
كما تقوم الشركة بكافة اعمال الصيانة بالاضافة لاعمال التوريدات (كهربية او ميكانيكية ) بالتركيب والتشغيل .
واليكم نبذة عن أحدث الماكينات المتوفرة و ماكينات التعبئة والتغليف في مصر

토토사이트추천 said...

I've been using WordPress on a number of websites for about a year and am worried about switching to another platform. I have heard good things about 토토사이트추천. Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress content into it? Any help would be really appreciated!

토토사이트순위 said...

Hello, I am one of the most impressed people in your article. 토토사이트순위 I'm very curious about how you write such a good article. Are you an expert on this subject? I think so. Thank you again for allowing me to read these posts, and have a nice day today. Thank you.

온라인바카라 said...

This is the post I was looking for 온라인바카라 I am very happy to finally read about the Thank you very much. Your post was of great help to me. If you are interested in the column I wrote, please visit my site .

feashason said...

replica bags online uae replica bags us 7a replica bags meaning

토토사이트순위 said...

I accidentally searched and visited your site. I still saw several posts during my visit, but the text was neat and readable. I will quote this post and post it on my blog. Would you like to visit my blog later? 토토사이트순위

메이저토토사이트 said...

This is the perfect post.메이저토토사이트 It helped me a lot. If you have time, I hope you come to my site and share your opinions. Have a nice day.

Bralin Allison said...

This was an awesome read and I have bookmarked your blog to keep up with new information. I just inform you that if you are planning to visit Turkey then a Turkish e visa is the best option to getting a visa because of its easy process and cost & time saving.

온라인바카라 said...

This informative blog is really interesting. It is a good blog I read some posts I was looking article like these. Thanks for sharing such informative. 온라인바카라

tepear said...

visit site replica ysl blog a fantastic read click this like this

electronic visa Turkey said...

The article you wrote has many valid points, despite the fact that I have read it many times. Your readers will benefit greatly from this content. Travelers can apply for an electronic visa Turkey which is very easy. You can apply online from any corner of the world. You only need an internet connection and valid documents.

Anonymous said...

شركات عزل الاسطح
شركات عزل

CLADING2222 said...

2- تعتبر حقن دوالي الساقين من العلاجات الفعالة لعلاج الدوالي، حيث يمكن أن تظهر النتائج بشكل سريع جداً، وبالتالي يمكن للمريض العودة إلى حياته الطبيعية بعد فترة وجيزة من العلاج.